Comoroto made his AEW debut back on the October 13, 2020, episode of Dark in a losing effort to Darby Allin. He has been ever-present on the YouTube show since mid-December and has primarily been used as an enhancement talent.
Comoroto turned many fans' heads after facing Jon Moxley on a recent edition of Dynamite and he secured his first win in AEW one week later in a six-man tag team match with The Natural Nightmares. He previously wrestled in WWE from February 2019 until April 2020 on the NXT live event circuit as Nick Ogarelli.
Aaron Solow has been a regular enhancement talent on Dark since July 2020 and has wrestled the likes of Rey Fenix, Sammy Guevara, Matt Sydal, Luchasaurus and Sonny Kiss. He recently formed a tag team with fellow Nightmare Family member Lee Johnson and they have so far amassed an 0-3 record.
The Nightmare family now includes Cody Rhodes, Brandi Rhodes, Diamond Dallas Page, Dustin Rhodes, QT Marshall, Arn Anderson, Lee Johnson, Gunn Club, Aaron Solow and Nick Comoroto.