10 Most Unlikeable WWE Babyfaces Ever

6. Randy Orton

Randy Orton eventually got very good at being a babyface, but it took him a while and some doubted he would ever get the hang of it after his first run as a good guy. 

The Legend Killer rapidly rose through the ranks as a member of Evolution and became genuinely hated in his disputes with some of WWE’s most beloved stars, like Mick Foley. It was actually his blowoff match with Foley – their excellent No Holds Barred scrap at Backlash 2004 – that led to the WWE audience changing their tune when it came to Orton. 

Impressed by Randy’s gutsy performance, fans started to warm to the then-Intercontinental Champion.

WWE, sensing the groundswell of support and want for a new star, had Orton drop the IC Title and upgrade to the World Heavyweight strap that summer. 

The following night, The Cerebral Assassin booted his understudy out of their group, cementing the turn. Then, sadly, The Viper bombed in the role due to his lack of likeability, his spot ultimately going to Batista while he turned back to the dark side.