Every WWE WrestleMania Rematch Ranked From Worst To Best

18. Randy Orton vs. Bray Wyatt - WrestleMania 37

At Elimination Chamber 2017, Bray Wyatt bested five other men to win his first WWE Championship, setting the stage for a big WrestleMania clash against his then-follower, Randy Orton. 

The Viper had spent months infiltrating The Wyatt Family, before finally turning on the cult leader by… burning down his shed? 

The match was even worse, featuring a big projector that flashed up images of bugs onto the ring mat. Orton then won anyway. 

Four years after this wet fart of a title match, Orton and Wyatt had the chance to do better at Mania 37. 

With Wyatt now in his Fiend era, this was the perfect opportunity for him to get revenge on The Apex Predator and avenge his loss. That isn’t what happened, though, and a Vince McMahon change of plans led to The Fiend losing following an RKO after Alexa Bliss became more powerful than him. This all happened after Orton set The Fiend on fire at TLC 2020. 

Both Orton and Wyatt matches were utter disasters, leaning way too heavily into the spooky side of Bray’s character, which distracted from the actual wrestling on display. 

Sadly, this would be Wyatt’s final appearance at The Show of Shows; an ignoble way to go out.